ACL History, Short Version

Updated 03/27/2004

I was not really having any problems until after surgery, in stark comparison to after first ACL reconstruction.

Injury and pre-op
1992 My Age 30: I was running 3 miles per day four to five days a week with neither left or right ACL's for the last 10 years plus.
1994 to 1996 My Age 32-34: Back pain, Left knee was swelling for the past ten years about two times a year with the strong impact.

Dr. Dickey:
08-29-96 My Age 34: Diagnosis, ACL torn in both knees ten to fifteen years previously.
09-11-96 My Age 34: ACL and meniscectomy of the right knee.
03-27-97 My Age 35: Interference screw bulging and removed in office. Never confidence in full extension. Two weeks solid moderate to severe pain after surgery, Extreme pain the night and next day after surgery. 95% activity possible pre-op on right knee 80 percent post-op two years after.

Dr. Lichota:
7-6-99 My Age 37: Second surgery meniscectomy and femur perforation to promote bleeding and regeneration, arthroscopy only. Little pain post-op. Eight months later even less flexion and extension than after first surgery and more sensitive to pressure on extension.

Haynes GP:
08-20-00 My Age 38: Referred to Dr. Cooke with fever and very sensitive, on crutches.

Dr. Cooke:
8-28-00 My Age 38: Third surgery. Septic infection. Post-op, little pain, but more loss of flexion and extension of six months previous. Over the last three years since the last surgery I have tried many alternatives, drugs, formal physical therapy twice and informal stretching and exercise for past three years.

Dr. Cooke
03/22/2004 My Age 42: Today I had another visit with Dr. Cooke. I need a new knee and I am unable to pay for it.

06/10/2004 I need a complete knee replacement still, but it is not that simple evidently there is an infection in the knee and they will cut out the infection and place the antibiotic cement on the bone and insert a antibiotic pad while I undergo IV antibiotics for 3 weeks prior to the knee replacement. I was told that there is an 85% percent chance of success with full extension and only my current 90 degrees of flexion to be expected. The remaining 15% is fusion of the joint, amputation of the leg or lastly death.

07/07/2004 Surprisingly, it looks as if the "system" the Texas Rehabilitation Commission and Medicaid is going to pay the $49k cost of my 4th knee surgery after all. I personally feel and most agree that my first surgeon, Dr. Robert Dickey, should be liable for this for anyway.

My schedule at Hendricks Hospital, (325) 670-2000, is:
07-21-2004 Surgery#1, removal of infected area and prep for TKR.
10 days in hospital on IV antibiotics.
07-31-2004 released to home in straight leg brace.
08-21-2004 Surgery#2, Knee Implant or TKR.


03/02/2004
Presently: Major instability and moderate to severe daily pain with normal daily activities this is not including the pain from work. Most any daily job, even office work, is to demanding. I have taken drugs that allowed me to pursue to my priority of work and school over the last two years. It is degenerating. My knee is my number one priority now to enable my previous priority of working, finishing school, with a move to another city required.

06/15/2004: Now it hurts like hell even when I am lying in bed much of the time. Looking back, which I must avoid, overall I got screwed.

Options: no surgery, continued use of drugs, difficulty finding work and completion of college.

Knee replacement: If my first surgery was due to my non-tolerance of surgery, my chances of betterment seem bad. If first surgery was the doctors fault my chances of betterment are increased. The expected life of the replacement knee is currently at 10-15 years before you will need another surgery.

Will I be able to stand in for how long daily, walk, bicycle, work, limits of ROM?
Details of procedure, complete A-Z.
Other options? Fuse, partial replacement, complete details of procedures.

From the other disabled persons profiles that I've read, I compare to the stoic or silent sufferer. Recently I took a trip to Denver. From Abilene to connect in DFW airport I was almost immobile upon reaching DFW.. I was more or less unable to move the rest of the two day business trip. Simple trips to the grocery store are sometimes almost impossible.

The first doctor, Dickey, made me feel as if my non-recovery was my fault. I now believe this was a delay tatic to get past the two year liability period. In my twenties and thirties I trained and raced motocross at a semi-pro level for fifteen years. I bicycled 1200 miles the years before the surgery and was running 3-5 miles two years before that. I worked full time since I was fifteen and the last three years I worked part-time while obtained a my associate's degree. I now see that my dedication to remedy my situation is not a question of my resolve. I've always believed that persistence and resolve is necessary for success yet I'm willing to accept my fate and deal with it with the same zeal no matter the limitations, once I am convinced it is the best I am able to obtain. I have high regard and confidence in my current physician Dr. Shannon Cooke, that he is able to do what is best for me and in his capability. I believe that he has the same confidence in his ability that he is confident he is able to do what is best for me. I have read and I also believe that these are two of the very important psychological factors that are necessary for the best possible outcome. This combined with the fact that he has already operated on me, my third surgery, once before.

Much of this information and more I found at:
http://www.niams.nih.gov
(National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases)

Here are the rest of my bookmarks for knee and health information:
Knee links:

"Austin" Sports Medicine: Orthopaedic and Sports Related Care These guys canceled my confirmed appointment after I drove 150 miles. One day before the appointment.
#1 ACLSolutions- ACL injury, knee pain and ACL knee surgery explained.
#1 Cincinnati Sportsmedicine Research and Education Foundation
#1 Google Search: total knee replacement
#1 Joint Surgeons of Sacramento: Total Knee Replacement
#1 Knee ACL from eOrthopod
#1 Kneeboard - SCAR TISSUE PEOPLE
#1- National Institute of Arthritis and Musculoskeletal and Skin Diseases Home Page
#1 YourMedicalSource.com
#1NIAMS - Publications Order Form
#2 AAOS
AAOS Online Service Fact Sheet Knee Implants
ACL SEARCH- Simple Search @ NML Locator
ACL: Anterior Cruciate Ligament
ACLSolutions- ACL injury, knee pain and ACL knee surgery explained.
Anterior Cruciate Ligament Tear Homepage
Arthritis Today: Joint Atlas
Arthritis.org Surgery Center - Flash Animations of Knee Surgeries
Combined Health Information Database
FLash for Knee Surgery
Hip implants, knee implants, biologic products, bone graft substitutes – Wright Medical
Knee1.com - ACL Reconstruction
Knee1.com - Dr. Frank Noyes
Knee1--Complete Source for Knee Information
knee-osteoarthritis-56k.asx
Legal.com
Legal.com and Legal Recourse: Legal Resources for Everyone(r)
Looking for a knee surgeon? The KNEEguru has a list of the big names in knee surgury around the world.
MayoClinic.com - Knee
McBride Clinic - Physicians
Medica Product Catalog - Knee Braces
MEDLINEplus
MEDLINEplus: Knee Injuries and Disorders
Michael Frind's Personal Homepage
MusculoGraphics Site Map
NIAMS Search Results - ACL complications
NIH: Health Information: Bones, Joints and Muscles
NZOA --New Zealand Orthopedic Association
Questions and Answers About Knee Problems
Re: Has anyone opted to not have surgery here?
Scott and White Hospital
Sports Medicine Orthopedic Surgeon - Houston TX - Dr. Walter Lowe, MD
sportsmetrics
 
Welcome to TMA: 'America's Best Medical Society'
Yahoo! Health - Diseases and Conditions

06-30-2004 Orthopedics - Search Results for In fection, orthopedics.about.com
#1 FCIC: Questions and Answers About Knee Problems
#1 How to Find Medical Information @ pueblo.gsa.gov
#1 MEDLINEplus Health Information from the National Library of Medicine
Abilene Regional Medical Center
Arthritis Today: The Disability Dance
Ask Dr. Weil - Q&amp
Matthew Lesko - Free Gov Money?????
Questions and Answers About Knee Problems
Yahoo! Health
Yahoo! Health - Disease, Condition, or General Health Topic

Questions to Ask Physician. These are just my present questions, which change everyday. What you ask your doctor should be tailored to your particular situation.
1. What operation are you recommending?
2. Why do I need the operation? and how will it help my ROM and pain
3. Are there alternatives to replacement surgery?
4. What are the benefits of having the operation?
5. What are the risks of having the operation? In general what %'s of ACL reconstruction's are successful?
6. What are %'s of successful knee replacements?
7. What has been your experience in doing the operation? Have you seen this condition after ACL surgery
before and what were the treatments and results?
8 . How long will it take me to recover from whatever procedure is recommended?
9 . How much will the operation cost?

More thorough information I have written about my ACL surgery and resulting condition.

Why not to have ACL surgery, anterior cruciate ligament